A public participation record should prove six things: people were told, they had the documents, they could respond, their views were kept, each view was considered, and they heard the outcome. Each case in Kenya's courts has turned on evidence. In the Finance Act case a committee report saved the law on this point, and in Nyabuto the absence of evidence helped sink one. The 2016 guidelines call record keeping "poor or non-existent".
Why is the record so important?
If your exercise is challenged, years may have passed, officers may have moved, and memories will have faded. The court can only rely on what is written down. In Nyabuto the respondents filed no replying affidavit at all, so the petitioner's evidence stood alone. A good record means someone can defend the work, even if the people who did it have gone.
What proves that people were told?
Keep each version of the notice, with the date and the place it appeared: the newspaper page, the radio script and the station's confirmation, dated photographs of notice boards, the web page, and any SMS. The notice template shows what the notice should contain.
What proves they had the documents?
Keep each document made available, including summaries and translations, with the date it was published and where. The Supreme Court said that different versions of a Bill should be made available. A document published after a forum doesn't help you, so dates matter.
What proves they could respond?
Keep the record of each forum: date, venue, time, language, the officers present, and how people with disabilities were supported. Keep the attendance list, but don't rely on it. The Supreme Court asks for both quantity and quality, and a list of names shows only that a meeting happened. Keep the email address and postal address used, and the closing date.
What proves views were kept?
Keep a log with a reference for each submission, its date, its channel and the original itself. Keep forum notes, and recordings if people agreed. Keep the original words, plus any translation.
What proves views were considered?
Keep the theme list, the coding, and a decision on each view or group of views: accepted, partly accepted, rejected or out of scope, with a reason, the name of the person who decided and the date. The Supreme Court's reasoning rested on a report that set out each proposal and whether it was accepted. Keep the versions of the document, to show what changed.
What proves people heard the outcome?
Keep the published report, and proof of how you shared it: web pages, radio scripts, notices and messages. If you reply to individuals, keep a record of what was sent and whether it arrived. A message handed to a gateway hasn't necessarily reached a person, so count the two separately.
What about who took part?
Compare those who took part with the population, and keep the workings. Who took part explains how. Name any group you failed to reach. An honest statement of a gap will serve you better than silence.
How should records be stored?
Keep them in one place, by exercise, with a simple index. The guidelines call for a standard storage and retrieval mechanism. Paper needs scanning, and files need backing up. Limit who can change them, and record any change. Mark who approved each document.
How long should you keep them?
Keep them at least as long as a challenge remains likely, and follow the retention rules that apply to your institution. Personal data should not be kept longer than needed, so separate names and contact details from the views. After a time you can remove personal details, and keep the summary.
How do you protect personal data?
A record holds names, phone numbers and sometimes sensitive views. Collect only what you need, tell people why, and restrict access. Publish only summaries, and be careful with anyone at risk because of what they said. Your institution remains responsible for this data under the Data Protection Act.
How can you show a record is genuine?
Date each item as it's made, and keep the originals. Sign the final report. A way to check that a printed copy matches the original helps, because copies can be altered once they circulate.
Who should check the record?
Have someone outside the exercise check it before the decision. Ask whether a stranger could tell what happened from the file alone. If not, fix it while you can.
A simple checklist
Before the decision is taken, check that the file holds:
- the plan, signed and dated;
- each notice, with proof of where and when it appeared;
- each document and summary, with its publication date;
- the record of each sitting, with language and attendance;
- the log of submissions, and the originals;
- the themes, and a decision and a reason on each view;
- the comparison of who took part with the population;
- the report, and proof of how it was shared;
- any complaints, and how they were answered.
If something is missing, write down why, and what you did about it. An honest note is better than a gap.
Read next
- Public participation system for Kenya: the TI pack page for this work
- Public participation software: all the pages in this section
- Deciding on every view
- Public participation report sample
- Public participation court rulings
- Takwimu Intelligence (TI) home page
- Public participation in Kenya: the guide to this library
- The TI platform and how we check our numbers
- File a public participation record
Where TI fits
Takwimu Intelligence (TI) keeps this record as the work happens, blocks a filing while something is missing, and lets anyone check a printed copy against the original.
To see it on your own consultation, book a walk-through.