Skip to content

method

Identical submissions in public participation: how to count a campaign

Four hundred identical memoranda are one argument and four hundred people. How to report both, why the Supreme Court accepted clusters, and what to do about duplicates.

Takwimu editorial team, Editorial team5 min read

Identical submissions should be reported twice: as one argument, and as the number of people who made it. Four hundred matching memoranda are one point, and they are also four hundred people who took the trouble to act. The Supreme Court accepted grouping such views: in the Finance Act 2023 case, emails were grouped in clusters, including 87 objecting to the Housing Levy and 137 calling for the Bill's rejection.

Why does it matter?

Campaign tools now let people send a ready-made memorandum with one click, and that is a legitimate way of taking part. In 2026, the Finance Bill drew memoranda from over 100,000 respondents. A public body has to handle that volume fairly, and two opposite errors are possible.

What are the two errors?

Both are common. The first is to reduce a campaign to one view. That understates the public, because it deletes hundreds of people from the account of who was heard. An institution may find that convenient, but a court won't.

The second is to treat them as hundreds of separate arguments. That overstates the debate, and leads to the same empty word, "noted", being entered hundreds of times.

What should you report?

Report both figures, side by side. For example: "The committee received 412 submissions on this clause, making one argument: that the levy should be removed. 400 used identical wording." Anyone reading it can see the scale and the substance.

What counts as identical?

Set your rule first, and publish it. A strict rule is the safest: treat submissions as identical after removing differences in capital letters, punctuation and spacing, leaving the words untouched. Two submissions that use different words aren't identical, even if they seem to make the same point. Grouping those is a judgement, so it should be made by a person, recorded as a theme, and named as such.

Should you reply to each person?

The Supreme Court said that Parliament isn't required to respond individually to every public comment or submission, and that it may group similar views into thematic areas. A single reasoned response to a group can meet that test. Each person's submission should still keep its own entry in your record.

What if some add a personal note?

Read them. People often add a line to a template about their own situation, and that line can be the most valuable part. Treat that extra text as a separate point, and record it.

What about fake or repeat submissions?

Check for this. A person might send the same message many times, or a tool might send messages in other people's names. Check for repeated addresses and bursts within seconds. Report what you find, without assuming bad faith. Don't delete anything silently: mark it, and keep it. If you exclude a submission, say how many, and why.

Should a campaign carry more weight?

A public body isn't bound by numbers. Public participation isn't a referendum, and the decision stays with the body responsible. Numbers do show strength of feeling, and they matter to how a decision is received. Weigh the arguments, and report the numbers in full.

How should you handle "reject the Bill entirely"?

The Supreme Court's review noted a cluster of 137 emails calling for rejection of the Bill in its entirety, and the committee didn't make an observation on that cluster. Your safest course is to record such views as a group, and say what you decided about them and why, even if that's brief.

How should you treat campaigns from organisations?

Record who organised the campaign if you know, and note it openly. Don't treat it as less valid, since organising is part of democracy. A union, a church or a traders' group speaking for its members adds something a single voice cannot.

What should your notice say?

Tell people in advance how you'll treat identical submissions. It helps people choose how to respond, and encourages them to add their own reasons. A line such as "you may use a template, but your own reason helps the committee" is enough.

How does this fit into your record?

Keep every entry, group them by your published rule, and give each group one reasoned decision. How to analyse public submissions covers the wider method.

A sample entry for your report

Take this invented example:

"Theme 3: market fees. The committee received 1,204 submissions on this theme. 1,150 used the same wording, asking that the fee stay at Sh30. 54 made other points, set out below. Decision on the 1,150: partly accepted. The fee is set at Sh40, because the county must pay for water and repairs. Of the 54, 12 asked for a lower rate for women's groups, which was accepted, and 42 raised matters outside this Bill, which were referred to the trade department."

A reader can see the numbers, the argument, the decision and the reason. Nobody has been erased from the record, and nobody has been counted as a separate argument without cause.

Where TI fits

On Takwimu Intelligence (TI), identical submissions are grouped after a stated rule, answered with one reasoned response, and each person keeps their own entry, so the record gives both figures.

To see it on your own consultation, book a walk-through.

Takwimu Intelligence (TI) is a public participation system for Kenya.

Sources

  1. 1

    British American Tobacco Kenya, PLC v Cabinet Secretary for the Ministry of Health and others, Supreme Court Petition 5 of 2017 · Supreme Court of Kenya (Koome CJ and six justices); the certified copy published by the Kenya Human Rights Commission137 pages. Paragraphs 104, 105, 132 to 161 and the orders at paragraph 249 read. The Supreme Court's own site lists the rulings of 30 August and 5 September 2024 in these petitions but not this judgment.

  2. 2

    House committee tables Finance Bill report · Uasin Gishu News, June 2026Over 100,000 respondents, and hearings in thirteen counties. Opened 5 November 2026.

More from the library