A public participation report should show what was being decided, how people were told, who took part, what they said, what was decided on each view and why, and how they can find out more. The Supreme Court upheld the Finance Act, 2023 on this point because the committee's report set out proposals from 161 persons and organisations, and whether each was accepted. A short, honest report like that is the best defence an institution has.
What should a report contain?
Use this format, and adapt it to the size of the exercise.
-
Summary. In half a page, give the decision, the dates, how many took part, the main findings and what changed.
-
The decision. Name the Bill, plan or policy, the body responsible and the legal basis.
-
How people were told. List each notice, with the date, the channel and the language.
-
What people were given. List documents and summaries, with the dates they became available.
-
How views were collected. List forums, memoranda and other channels, with dates and venues.
-
Who took part. Give numbers by ward, sex and age group, compared with the population, and name any group that was not reached.
-
What was said. Group views into themes, with how many people held each one.
-
What was decided. For each view or group of views, say whether it was accepted, partly accepted, rejected or out of scope, and why.
-
What changed. List the changes made to the document.
-
Next steps. Say what happens now, and how to raise a concern.
Annexes can hold attendance lists, notices, and copies of memoranda, with personal details protected.
A sample table
Set out the treatment of views in a table with these columns: reference, proposal, from whom, decision and reason. Take an invented example.
Reference 14: "Reduce the kiosk fee from Sh5,000 to Sh3,000", from the market traders' association and 62 individuals. Partly accepted. The fee is set at Sh4,000 and phased over two years, because the cost of market services has risen.
Reference 15: "Build a new bus park in the ward". Out of scope for this Bill. Referred to the roads department for the next annual development plan.
What did the Supreme Court look for?
In the Finance Act case the Court found that the committee had received 1,080 memoranda, and that under each of 161 persons and organisations the report outlined the proposal and the committee's observation on whether to accept it. Emails were grouped in clusters, such as 87 objecting to the Housing Levy. The Court said the report must be clear enough to enable those who submitted views to understand that their input was considered. Parliament wasn't required to respond individually to every comment, and could group similar views into themes.
What did the High Court find missing in Nairobi?
In Nyabuto, the Court found no evidence of consideration of public input or of feedback mechanisms explaining what was accepted or rejected. A report would have answered that. It is often the first thing a court asks to see.
How long should it be?
As long as the exercise needs, with a short summary at the front. The 2016 guidelines say the governor's report should be brief, direct and simple for the public to understand, and they give a model format. The Makueni budget participation report is a public example worth looking at.
How should you group views?
Group by theme, and show how many people held each view. Don't reduce an organised campaign to a single line, because that hides how many people took part. Handling identical submissions explains how to report both figures.
Should you name individuals?
Name organisations that made submissions. For private individuals, use a reference or initials unless they have agreed to be named. A report is public, so protect personal details, and take special care with anyone who may be at risk.
When should it be published?
The guidelines' timeline suggests communicating the outcome within seven days of a forum. A full report may take longer, but publish it before the decision is taken if you can. It would be hard to claim that views shaped a decision if the report came out after it.
Where should it be published?
Put it on your website, and send a short version through the channels you used for notice. Under the Public Participation Bill, the authority would have to prepare a report as soon as is practicable. Keep the printed version the same as the online one, and be ready to prove it.
Who should sign it?
The responsible officer should sign and date it. It helps to note who analysed the views, and who made each decision. Deciding on every view covers that step.
How do you write the summary?
Be brief. Most readers stop at the first page, so give them the whole story in a few lines. Take this invented example:
"Between 26 January and 13 February, the county consulted on the Trade Licensing Bill. It held six forums attended by 412 people, received 87 memoranda and surveyed 300 traders. Women made up 38% of those at forums, against 51% of traders in the survey, so we held two extra sessions with women's groups. Of 64 proposals, 21 were accepted, 12 partly accepted, 24 rejected and 7 were out of scope. The main change is a lower fee for stalls under three metres."
A reader now knows what happened, who was reached, and what changed. The rest of the report backs that up.
Read next
- Public participation system for Kenya: the TI pack page for this work
- Running a public participation exercise: all the pages in this section
- Deciding on every view
- Reporting back after public participation
- Who took part
- Takwimu Intelligence (TI) home page
- Public participation in Kenya: the guide to this library
- The TI platform and how we check our numbers
- File a public participation record
Where TI fits
Takwimu Intelligence (TI) builds this report from the record itself, stops it from being issued while a view has no decision, and lets anyone check a printed copy against the original.
To see it on your own consultation, book a walk-through.