Skip to content

guide

Reporting back, and proving the report is genuine

A consultation ends when the people who took part can find out what happened to their views. That means publishing the outcome where residents will see it, replying on the channels they used, and giving any reader a way to check that a printed report is the one the county issued.

Takwimu editorial team, Editorial team6 min read

Reporting back is the step most consultations skip, and it is the one residents notice. A person who made a submission and heard nothing concludes the exercise was for show, and the next consultation starts with fewer people willing to take part. The law requires the national and county governments to publish their main budget documents, and the courts have looked closely at whether a body's response to public views was public and readable. Done well, reporting back has three parts. The outcome is published where residents will see it, each person who took part can learn what happened to their own view, and the published report can be checked against the original. This piece covers all three.

What the law requires a county to publish

The Public Finance Management Act sets publication deadlines at each stage of the budget. The annual development plan must be published and publicised "within seven days after its submission to the county assembly" (section 126(4)), and the County Fiscal Strategy Paper within seven days of its submission (section 117(8)). The approved budget estimates must be consolidated, published and publicised "not later than twenty-one days after the county assembly has approved" them (section 131(5)), in "a form that is clear and easily understood by, and readily accessible to, members of the public" (section 131(6)). The National Treasury's budget manual adds that the county treasury "should also publish a Citizens Budget which explains and summarizes the budget" (paragraph 93). Outside the budget, section 92(2) of the County Governments Act requires the governor to report to the county assembly every year on citizen participation.

These provisions say the outcome must be public. They say less about the views that shaped it. That part comes from the courts.

What the courts look for in a report

In the Finance Act judgment of October 2024, the Supreme Court asked whether the National Assembly's committee report served "as a reasonable feedback mechanism that facilitates accountability and transparency in providing the public with feedback on the fate of their proposals" (paragraph 151). It found that the report did, partly because "as a public document, it is accessible to members of the public, ensuring that institutions and individuals who participate in public participation exercises related to the Bill can access it" (paragraph 157). The test it set was that the record be "clear enough to enable those who submitted their views to understand that their input was considered and given due attention" (paragraph 150). The court also recommended that every version of a Bill be made available to the public "in a simple format" at every stage (paragraph 160). Access matters as much as content. The High Court's finding in Nyabuto shows the opposite case: it found "no evidence of consideration of public inputs or feedback mechanisms explaining acceptance or rejection of views", and quashed the county's finance act.

So the report residents are given should be the record of decisions itself, or a faithful summary that points to it, and it should be published before or when the decision takes effect. A report that only states the final budget figures tells nobody what happened to their submission.

Replying on the channels people used

Publication on a website reaches the residents who were already best placed to take part. A person who sent an SMS, called a radio programme or handed a memorandum in at a ward forum is better reached the same way. A reply by SMS can carry the outcome and say where the full reason can be read, because cutting a reason short to fit a message changes what the county told that person. A radio caller cannot be written to individually, so the county answers on the same programme, to the audience. Replies need the language the person used, too. Recording each reply, its channel, its date and whether it was delivered turns reporting back from an intention into something the county can show. Sent and delivered are different things. The record keeps them apart.

Proving the report is genuine

A published participation report travels. It is printed, forwarded, quoted in petitions and sometimes altered. A county that issues its report with a fingerprint of the file, and a public page where anyone can check a copy against that fingerprint, gives every reader a way to tell the genuine report from an edited one. The check needs no account and no trust in whoever forwarded the copy.

Did reporting back make a difference?

A county can measure whether its reporting back reached people and changed how they see the consultation. A follow-up survey can ask residents whether they were told what happened to the views, and whether they believe their views were considered, and compare the answers of those who were told with those who were not. That comparison is a description. It shows whether the two groups differ, and a careful report does not call the difference an effect of the feedback unless some residents were left out of it on purpose, as a comparison group. Measured year after year, it shows whether the next consultation starts with more trust or less.

Where Takwimu fits

On Takwimu a reply to every answered view is queued on the channel the view arrived on, in its language, and the record shows which replies were sent and which were delivered; an SMS reply goes through the county's own gateway account. The participation report is issued under the county's name, hash stamped, with a public verification page. The pack's indicators include residents told what happened to the views, residents who believed their views were considered, and the gap between those told and not told.

To see a consultation's report back and its verification page, book a walk-through.

Takwimu Intelligence (TI) is a public participation system for Kenya.

Sources

  1. 1

    Public Finance Management Act, No. 18 of 2012 · National Council for Law Reporting, as enacted; the copy hosted by the World BankSections 117(8), 126(4), 131(5) and 131(6). Opened 29 October 2026.

  2. 2

    County Government Budget Manual 2024 · The National Treasury and Economic PlanningParagraph 93, on publishing the budget and a Citizens Budget. Opened 29 October 2026.

  3. 3

    Cabinet Secretary for the National Treasury and Planning & 4 others v Okiya Omtatah Okoiti & 52 others, Petitions E031, E032 and E033 of 2024 (consolidated), judgment of 29 October 2024 · Supreme Court of Kenya; the certified copy published by the Kenya Human Rights CommissionParagraphs 136, 150, 151, 157 and 160. Opened 29 October 2026.

  4. 4

    Nyabuto v County Assembly of Nairobi City County & 2 others, Petition E040 of 2025, judgment of 19 June 2025 · High Court at Milimani (Mwamuye J); Kenya LawKenya Law's text, saved from a browser and read 29 October 2026.

  5. 5

    County Governments Act, No. 17 of 2012, Revised Edition 2020 · National Council for Law Reporting; the copy in the County Assemblies Forum's repositorySection 92(2). Opened 29 October 2026.

More from the library

  • Who took part, against who lives there

    A count of attendees says how many came. Comparing them with the census population by sex and age says whether the consultation heard the people the decision falls on, and names the groups it missed. How to make the comparison, and how to read it.

  • Running a public consultation on Takwimu

    One consultation from start to finish: open the decision, record the notice, the documents and each sitting, collect views from every channel, decide on each, compare who took part with the census population, issue the filing and reply to everyone who took part.

  • Reaching everyone a decision affects

    A consultation is judged first on who could take part. That depends on a notice that says what is being decided and where to read it, documents people can understand, the languages and formats the Constitution names, and channels that reach residents who never attend a forum.