Skip to content

guide

What the courts have said about public participation

Five judgments set the standard a public consultation is tested against, national or county, from Gakuru in 2014 to the Nairobi finance act quashed in June 2025. Read together, they ask a public body for evidence: what residents were told, what they were given to read, and what was done with what they said.

Takwimu editorial team, Editorial team9 min read

Kenyan courts have spent a decade deciding what public participation requires, and five judgments carry most of the weight for a county. In 2014 the High Court in Gakuru held that a county assembly passing taxes and levies carries a heavier duty to reach the public. In 2019 the Supreme Court set out the guiding principles every public body is held to. In July 2024 the Court of Appeal struck down the whole Finance Act, 2023, partly because Parliament gave no reasons for rejecting the public's proposals, and in October 2024 the Supreme Court reinstated the Act while setting out what a body must do with the views it receives. In June 2025 the High Court quashed the Nairobi City County Finance Act, 2023 and every new levy under it. Each case turned on evidence. This piece reads them in order, from their own texts.

Gakuru, 2014: a heavier duty when the law is about taxes

Robert N. Gakuru and others brought consolidated petitions against the Governor of Kiambu County and three others, and Justice Odunga's judgment became one of the most cited in this field. The Supreme Court quoted its central passage in full in BAT (paragraph 95), and it is worth reading slowly. Public participation, the judge wrote, "ought to be real and not illusory and ought not to be treated as a mere formality", and county assemblies must ensure it is attained "both quantitatively and qualitatively". He went on: "It is not just enough in my view to simply 'tweet' messages as it were and leave it to those who care to scavenge for it." Where the legislation involves "payment of taxes and levies, the duty is even more onerous", and the assembly should use "churches, mosques, temples, public barazas national and vernacular radio broadcasting stations and other avenues where the public are known to converge". That passage is a description of reach. A county that can show which of those avenues it used, in which wards and in which languages, is answering the question Gakuru asks.

BAT, 2019: the Supreme Court's principles

In British American Tobacco Kenya v the Cabinet Secretary for Health, the Supreme Court used its power to set a framework for public participation that applies to all of governance (paragraph 96). It held that the duty sits with the public officer or body charged with the decision, and that "the lack of a prescribed legal framework for public participation is no excuse for not conducting public participation". Participation "must be real and not illusory. It is not a cosmetic or a public relations act." It "must be accompanied by reasonable notice and reasonable opportunity", judged case by case. The court also set limits on what a challenger can claim: "The fact that someone was not heard is not enough to annul the process." The court then listed the components of meaningful participation:

  • clarity of the subject matter for the public to understand;
  • structures and processes of participation that are clear and simple;
  • opportunity for balanced influence from the public in general;
  • commitment to the process;
  • inclusive and effective representation;
  • integrity and transparency of the process;
  • capacity to engage on the part of the public, including that the public must first be sensitised on the subject matter.

Several of these are things a county can measure. Inclusive and effective representation, for one, can be tested by comparing who took part with who lives in the county.

The Finance Act 2023: two appellate courts on reasons

The Court of Appeal's judgment of 31 July 2024 declared the entire Finance Act, 2023 unconstitutional on two separate grounds. The first concerned the budget process: the Act was enacted in violation of Articles 220(1)(a) and 221 and the PFM Act's budget provisions (order vi). The second concerned public participation. The court held that "Parliament after conducting public participation is obligated to give reasons for rejecting or adopting the proposals received" (paragraph 190), and that failing to do so "renders the entire Finance Act, 2023 unconstitutional" (order vii). Its reasoning was blunt. Insulating Parliament from the duty to explain why public views were rejected, it said, "is the surest way of rendering public participation illusory, cosmetic and a mere formality or public relations exercise" (paragraph 189).

The Supreme Court reversed that finding on 29 October 2024, and what it said instead matters more to a county than any headline about the case. It held that law-making is not administrative action, so the right to written reasons in Article 47(2) does not attach to it (paragraphs 138 to 142), and that Article 118(1) imposes only a duty to facilitate participation (paragraph 143). It then held "that, while there is no express obligation on Parliament to provide reasons for accepting and/or rejecting proposals/views made during a public participation exercise, as a matter of good practice, it must nonetheless put in place reasonable measures to guide how Parliament considers and treats the proposals" (paragraph 148). The court described what a reasonable measure looks like. The record "must be clear enough to enable those who submitted their views to understand that their input was considered and given due attention", the body "is not required to respond individually to every public comment", and it may "group similar views into thematic areas and address them collectively" (paragraph 150).

The Act survived because of the committee's report. The court found that the Departmental Committee on Finance had received 1,080 memoranda and that, in 235 pages, its report considered the views of 161 persons and organisations: "Under each of the 161 persons and organizations, the Report outlines the proposal made and the Committee's observation on whether to accept or reject the proposal" (paragraph 153). Emails were grouped into clusters, such as 87 objecting to the housing levy and 137 calling for the Bill's rejection in its entirety, with an observation made on each cluster except the last (paragraph 155). The report, the court said, "to a large extent ... strives to explain the reasons for accepting or rejecting various proposals" and was public (paragraph 157). So the court held "there is no sufficient basis to invalidate a public participation exercise on the grounds that Parliament did not provide reasons to every individual participant" (paragraph 159). It also held that amendments introduced to give effect to views gathered in participation need no fresh round of participation (paragraph 132). The court set aside the declaration that the whole Act was unconstitutional, while upholding the finding that sections 76, 78 and 87 were unconstitutional because they were not connected to a money Bill (paragraph 249).

For a county the lesson is precise. The Supreme Court did not require a reply to every person. It accepted a record that set out each proposal and whether it was accepted or rejected, grouped where the views were the same, and published. That is a standard a county assembly can meet, and it is one that binds county bodies too, because Article 10's values bind "all State organs" in the Constitution's own words. Deciding on every view sets out how to keep such a record.

Nyabuto, 2025: a county finance act quashed

In Nyabuto, decided on 19 June 2025, a Nairobi resident challenged the Nairobi City County Finance Act, 2023. None of the respondents filed a reply, so the petition was decided unopposed. The court accepted that the county "did not develop, adopt, publish, or implement any tariffs and pricing policy before enacting the impugned Finance Act", which section 120 of the County Governments Act requires, and that "public participation involved presenting schedules of proposed fees without underlying policy or cost analyses". Forums, "if held, were based on mere schedules of numbers without policy context", which the court called "tokenistic consultation". It found that the lack of information "disproportionately affected less educated, rural, or disadvantaged residents", and that "there is no evidence of consideration of public inputs or feedback mechanisms explaining acceptance or rejection of views".

The orders were severe. The court declared the Act unconstitutional, against Articles 196 and 201 of the Constitution and section 120 of the County Governments Act, and quashed it. Every new levy, rate and fee imposed under it was quashed, and the charges under the Nairobi City County Finance Act of 2022 or earlier were to apply until a new Finance Act complying with the judgment was passed. It also declared that residents' rights to participation, to information under Article 35 and to expression under Article 33 had been violated. Nyabuto adds a point the Finance Act cases did not need to make. Residents can only comment on what they are shown, so the policy and costing behind a fee are part of the consultation.

What the judgments ask a county to keep

Taken in order, the cases move from whether a consultation happened to what the public body can show about it. A county that wants to stand on firm ground keeps four things from the start. It keeps the notice and every document residents were given, including the policy behind any fee, with the dates they were made available. It keeps a record of where and how residents were reached, which is what Gakuru and BAT ask about. It keeps each view, or each group of identical views, with what was decided about it and why, which is the record the Supreme Court accepted in 2024 and the record Nyabuto found missing. And it publishes the result where the people who took part can read it, which is covered in reporting back. None of it can be rebuilt later.

Where Takwimu fits

Takwimu holds that record as the consultation runs. Each view is marked accepted, partly accepted, rejected or out of scope, with a written reason and the name of the officer who decided, and identical submissions can be answered with one reasoned response while each person's view keeps its own entry. Decisions are never overwritten: a correction is added as a new entry under its author's name.

To see a decision record of the kind the Supreme Court described, book a walk-through.

Takwimu Intelligence (TI) is a public participation system for Kenya.

Sources

  1. 1

    British American Tobacco Kenya, PLC v Cabinet Secretary for the Ministry of Health & 2 others, Petition No. 5 of 2017, judgment of 26 November 2019 · Supreme Court of KenyaParagraphs 89, 95 and 96. Paragraph 95 quotes paragraph 75 of Robert N. Gakuru & others v Governor Kiambu County & 3 others [2014] eKLR, which is how Gakuru is cited here. Opened 29 October 2026.

  2. 2

    National Assembly & another v Okiya Omtatah Okoiti & others, Civil Appeal No. E003 of 2023 (consolidated), judgment of 31 July 2024 · Court of Appeal at Nairobi (M'Inoti, Murgor and Mativo JJ.A.); the copy published by the Kenya Human Rights Commission, the 15th respondentParagraphs 189 and 190 and final orders (vi) and (vii). Opened 29 October 2026.

  3. 3

    Cabinet Secretary for the National Treasury and Planning & 4 others v Okiya Omtatah Okoiti & 52 others, Petitions E031, E032 and E033 of 2024 (consolidated), judgment of 29 October 2024 · Supreme Court of Kenya; the certified copy published by the Kenya Human Rights CommissionParagraphs 104, 132, 136 to 161 and the orders at paragraph 249. Opened 29 October 2026.

  4. 4

    Nyabuto v County Assembly of Nairobi City County & 2 others; Commission on Revenue Allocation (Interested Party), Petition E040 of 2025, judgment of 19 June 2025 · High Court at Milimani, Constitutional and Human Rights Division (Bahati Mwamuye J); Kenya LawThe analysis and the orders. Kenya Law's text, saved from a browser and read 29 October 2026; that copy carries no paragraph numbers.

  5. 5

    The Constitution of Kenya, 2010 · Parliament of KenyaArticle 10(1). Opened 29 October 2026.

More from the library

  • What the law requires of public participation in Kenya

    The Constitution makes participation a value that binds every State organ, and a duty of Parliament and of every county assembly. Parliament's Standing Orders, the County Governments Act and the Public Finance Management Act add the rules and name the officers answerable for the budget. Here is each provision, and the record it asks a public body to hold.

  • The county budget calendar: what a county consults on, and when

    The Public Finance Management Act fixes the dates of the county budget year, from the circular by 30 August to the Finance Bill within 90 days of the Appropriation Bill, and the County Governments Act adds the plans and reports on a longer cycle. Every date, with the section behind it and where the public comes in.

  • Kenya Policy on Public Participation: what Sessional Paper No. 3 says

    Kenya's public participation policy sets national standards in nine priority areas for both levels of government. What it asks of a public body, how it differs from the Bill, and how to apply it.