Makueni is the county other governors were sent to learn from. In August 2018 the Council of Governors held its first governors' peer learning mission there, and its knowledge-sharing report on the Makueni model describes what they saw. Makueni organises participation through elected development committees at every level from the village to the county. Residents identify projects at village forums, and the committees prioritise and validate them on the way up. It describes a structure well. It records far less about the views residents gave and what was done with them, and that is the part a court asks about. This piece follows the report page by page, then sets out what a county running the model still needs to keep.
The mission and the problem it answered
The mission grew out of frustration. At a governance summit in March 2018, convened by the Council with support from USAID's AHADI programme, governors said they wanted to engage citizens but were held back: "citizens were asking for money to turn up for public participation. Hence, low attendance marked the events" (page 5). They also named "the poor representation of middle-income groups as another challenge" (page 5). Makueni's governor told the summit his county had overcome these problems by building structures from the grassroots, and the Council chose it for a two-day pilot mission on 26 and 27 August 2018 (page 6), organised with AHADI, the World Bank and NEPAD (page 7). The report grounds the model in the Constitution, citing Article 10 and Article 174(c), and names the County Governments Act, the Public Finance Management Act and the Urban Areas and Cities Act as laws that "give prominence to public participation" (page 4).
How the model is organised
The village is the starting point. The report explains that "the village is the focal point of interaction of citizens" because villagers meet regularly whether or not the government calls them (page 13). From there, communities elected development committee members "representing villages, the cluster of villages, sub-wards, wards, sub-counties and to the larger county level" (page 13). The structure has five named tiers: village, sub-ward, ward and sub-county development committees, and a county development committee at the top (page 14). "Each committee comprises 11 members made up of men, women, youths, people with disabilities, and other marginalised groups" (page 13). The committees serve three years, and their members "are not political appointees. It is the citizens who vote them in" (page 15).
Projects move up through the tiers. The Kwa Mbila earth dam is the report's example: it was "identified at village level forums, prioritised at the sub-ward level and validated at ward level", is managed at the ward development committee, and has a project management committee drawn from the three wards it serves; it cost Ksh7 million (page 10). Makueni's universal health care programme followed the same road, prioritised from the village level in 2015/16 through the cluster, sub-ward, ward and sub-county to the annual people's forum, and validated as a headquarters project (page 11). The report adds that there is "a 30 per cent representation of women in the project management committees" (page 15), that members of the county assembly have an oversight role but "cannot alter the trajectory of any development projects in the ward" (page 15), and that the sub-county committee handles grievances about abuse of resources or failed projects (page 15).
Civic education came first. "The County Government trained 900 people through 30 civic education trainers", and the 900 trained citizens in turn on the Constitution, county government and public finance (page 13). The report credits this with the absence of the problem governors had raised: "nobody gets paid any allowances to be involved in county forums" (page 15).
What the report recommends
The mission produced an outline for other counties (page 3, repeated on page 19). It runs from participatory structures and planning to participatory budgeting, management and evaluation, and under evaluation it proposes that residents "should give their approvals before contractors are paid". It closes with "Integration of Technology: Use of technologies such as GIS (Geographic Information System), Bulk SMS, PP/e Portal, Project Management System, Complaint Management System and more help to promote efficiency and enhance public participation."
The visiting governors' own conclusions point the same way. Among their "eye openers" they wrote that "it is important too to integrate technology to manage data, expand information sharing and enable the contribution of ideas" (page 17). Among the hindrances they listed nomadic movement among pastoralist communities, demands for sitting allowances, political conflicts among county leaders and the "lack of a structured public participation system that is understood by all players" (page 17). Both lists point to records.
What the report leaves unwritten
The report describes who sits on each committee, how a project rises through the tiers and what residents built. It gives no attendance figures for any forum. It does not say how many proposals were made at village level, which were dropped on the way up, or why. It reports no response to residents whose proposals failed, and its measure of representation is the committee's composition, not a count of who took part against who lives in the ward or the county. None of that diminishes what Makueni built, and the report's own call for "a structured public participation system" and technology "to manage data" suggests the governors knew it.
Those records now matter in court. The Supreme Court's 2024 judgment on the Finance Act turned on a report that set out each proposal and whether it was accepted, and the High Court quashed Nairobi's finance act in 2025 partly for want of any record "explaining acceptance or rejection of views"; what the courts have said reads both. A county running Makueni's structure still needs to keep, for each consultation, the views each forum heard, the decision on each with its reason, and a comparison of who took part with the county's population. Deciding on every view and who took part explain how.
Where Takwimu fits
Takwimu keeps the record the report leaves unwritten. For each decision a county consults on, it holds every view with the channel it arrived on, the decision on each with its reason and the officer who made it, a comparison of who took part with the county's 2019 census population, and the replies sent back. It sits alongside whatever committee structure a county runs.
To see how a county's consultations are recorded on the platform, book a walk-through.