Skip to content

guide

County finance bill and public participation: fees, levies and the law

County finance laws set the fees people pay every day. The Nairobi and Kiambu rulings show what happens when a county skips proper participation.

Takwimu editorial team, Editorial team6 min read

A county finance bill sets the fees, charges and levies a county collects, from market stalls to parking and business permits. These are the laws people feel most directly, and they have been struck down when public participation fell short. In June 2025 the High Court quashed the Nairobi City County Finance Act, 2023 and every new levy under it, and the Gakuru ruling of 2014 said that where taxes and levies are involved "the duty is even more onerous".

Key points:

  • The county finance bill goes to the assembly with the revenue measures.
  • It must be considered within 90 days after the Appropriation Bill passes.
  • Section 120 of the County Governments Act requires a tariffs and pricing policy.
  • People need a reason for each charge as well as a list of figures.

What is a county finance bill?

It is the Bill that gives a county the legal power to collect its revenue for the year. It usually comes with schedules of fees for trade licences, markets, parking, land rates, health services and more. Under Article 209 a county may impose only certain taxes, and charges for services it provides.

When does it happen?

Under sections 132 and 133 of the Public Finance Management Act, the county executive member for finance submits the County Finance Bill to the assembly on the same date that revenue-raising measures are announced. The assembly must consider and approve it, with or without amendments, not later than 90 days after passing the Appropriation Bill.

Why does a tariff policy matter?

Section 120(1) of the County Governments Act says that a county government or any agency delivering services shall adopt and implement a tariffs and pricing policy. In Nyabuto, the High Court found that Nairobi had not developed, adopted, published or implemented such a policy before enacting the Act. That was central to the case: without a policy, residents could not see why a charge was set at a given level.

What did the Nairobi ruling decide?

The findings were blunt. The Court held that public participation "must not be cosmetic or superficial". It found that forums were based on schedules of numbers without policy context, and it called this "tokenistic consultation". It also found no evidence that views were considered, or of any feedback. It noted that the lack of information fell hardest on less educated, rural or disadvantaged residents. The Act was declared unconstitutional under Articles 196 and 201, and section 120.

What did Gakuru decide?

In Gakuru, the High Court dealt with a Kiambu County finance law. As the Supreme Court quoted in BAT, the judge said that it isn't enough to simply "tweet" messages, and that assemblies should use as many forums as possible, including churches, mosques, temples, public barazas, and national and vernacular radio stations.

What should a county do?

Prepare in this order:

  • adopt and publish a tariffs and pricing policy;
  • explain each proposed change, with the reason and the cost of the service;
  • publish the Bill and a plain summary;
  • take the schedules to the people they affect, such as traders at the market itself;
  • record who came and what they said;
  • show how the Bill changed as a result.

What should a trader or resident do?

Get the schedule, and compare it with last year's. If a charge has jumped, ask why. Bring others who pay the same fee, because a group speaking with one voice is easier to record. Say what would work instead: a lower rate, a phased rise, or a better service in return. Write to the county assembly's finance committee, and attend the hearing.

Can a county charge before the law passes?

A county should collect only what the law allows, and a law that a court quashes can no longer support a charge. In Nyabuto the Court quashed the Act and every new levy under it. The order against the county went no further, because it noted that the respondents did attempt to undertake their duty, though largely ineffectively.

What about existing fees?

Where a Finance Act is struck down, questions arise about which earlier rates apply. Seek advice on your case, since the answer depends on the orders the court made.

How should feedback be given?

The Supreme Court said people should be able to understand that their input was considered. For a fee schedule, a simple table works: the proposal, the views received, what the county decided, and why. Publish it with the final Act.

What does this cost a county?

A successful challenge can cost the county a year's revenue measures, along with legal fees and lost trust. Compared with that, an honest consultation costs little. It is also the surest route to fees people will pay.

How do you read a fee schedule?

Lay last year's schedule beside this year's, and mark every change. Look for three things: new charges, large rises, and charges that have moved from a yearly to a daily or per-trip basis, since those can multiply what you pay. Work out what the change means for one business or household over a year.

Then ask what the fee pays for. If a county charges a market fee, it should be able to say what cleaning, security and lighting it provides. Section 120 expects a pricing policy behind each charge, so it's reasonable to ask to see it. A trader who says "this rise means Sh18,000 more a year, and the market has no water" gives a committee something real to weigh.

Where TI fits

Takwimu Intelligence (TI) gives a county the record the courts look for: who was told, what they were shown, what they said and how the Bill changed.

To see it on your own consultation, book a walk-through.

Takwimu Intelligence (TI) is a public participation system for Kenya.

Sources

  1. 1

    Nyabuto v County Assembly of Nairobi City County & 2 others; Commission on Revenue Allocation (Interested Party), Petition E040 of 2025, [2025] KEHC 8865 (KLR), High Court, judgment of 19 June 2025 · High Court at Milimani, Constitutional and Human Rights Division (Bahati Mwamuye J); Kenya LawKenya Law refuses scripted requests, so the owner saved its text from a browser as a Word file (JUDGMENT-NAIROBIPETITIONE040OF2025.docx, kept out of the repository). The copy carries no paragraph numbers, so the judgment is cited without them.

  2. 2

    British American Tobacco Kenya, PLC v Cabinet Secretary for the Ministry of Health & 2 others, Petition No. 5 of 2017, Supreme Court, judgment of 26 November 2019 · Supreme Court of Kenya63 pages. Paragraphs 89, 95 and 96 (the guiding principles for public participation) read. Paragraph 95 quotes paragraph 75 of the High Court's judgment in Robert N. Gakuru & others v Governor Kiambu County & 3 others (Petition No. 532 of 2013, consolidated) [2014] eKLR, which is how Gakuru is cited here: Kenya Law's copy refuses scripted requests.

  3. 3

    The Constitution of Kenya, 2010 · Parliament of Kenya193 pages with a text layer. Articles 1, 7, 10, 35, 47, 54, 118, 174, 196, 201, 220 and 232 read.

  4. 4

    Public Finance Management Act, No. 18 of 2012 · National Council for Law Reporting, the edition as enacted, hosted by the World Bank192 pages. Sections 117, 118, 125, 126, 128, 129, 131, 132, 133, 137 and 207 read. The dates are checked against the National Treasury's County Government Budget Manual 2024 (source 4), which states the same deadlines.

  5. 5

    County Governments Act, No. 17 of 2012, Revised Edition 2020 · National Council for Law Reporting, in the County Assemblies Forum's repository87 pages. Sections 87 to 92 (Part VIII), 96, 97, 108, 115 and 120 read. Section 91A (County Development Boards, inserted by Act No. 13 of 2014) is not relied on.

More from the library