The main challenges of public participation in Kenya are late notice, documents people cannot understand, low and unrepresentative attendance, demands for payment, limited civic education, poor record keeping and a lack of feedback. Most of these are old problems. The 2016 guidelines named several of them a decade ago, and the High Court found some of the same failures in Nairobi in 2025.
Key findings:
- Governors have reported low attendance and citizens asking for money to turn up.
- The guidelines say that record keeping has been "poor or non-existent".
- The High Court has called schedules of numbers without a policy "tokenistic consultation".
- Each problem has a practical remedy, and most cost less than losing a law in court.
Why is attendance low?
People attend when they believe it will change something. In March 2018, governors told a Council of Governors summit that citizens were asking for money to turn up, and that low attendance marked the events. They also reported poor representation of middle-income groups. The guidelines make the same point about lethargy, and say thresholds for attendance should be left to county governments.
A remedy starts with what people see. The guidelines suggest that when the public can see the fruits of their participation, that may act as an incentive to keep taking part. So report back, and name the projects that changed because of residents' views.
Should people be paid to attend?
The guidelines note that compensation in the form of transport, meals and per diems is not sustainable for county governments. In the Makueni model, nobody is paid allowances to take part in county forums. Paying attendance can also change who comes and why. If you do cover transport for people who could not otherwise attend, such as persons with disabilities, say so in your record.
Why do people get notice too late?
Notice often goes out late or in the wrong place: a newspaper few residents buy, or a website few residents open. The guidelines set seven days for notice of a forum and 14 days for documents. Use the channels people use, including vernacular radio, chiefs' barazas, churches, mosques and notice boards. Reaching everyone a decision affects goes through this in detail.
Why don't people understand the documents?
A 200-page budget is not an invitation. In Nyabuto, the High Court found that participants lacked substantive material, and that the lack of information fell hardest on less educated, rural or disadvantaged residents who could not analyse schedules without policy guides. Publish a short summary in plain language, in Kiswahili as well as English, and in a local language where it is needed.
What about civic education?
The guidelines say it cannot be assumed that officials and the public have the capacity to engage, and that understanding of the roles of different actors is limited. Civic education is a county duty under the County Governments Act. Civic education in Kenya covers what that means. Build a short explanation into each forum, since that is when people are listening.
Who gets left out?
Forums tend to attract people who have time, confidence and transport. The guidelines ask whether counties have mechanisms to include youth, women, older people, persons with disabilities and marginalised groups. The Council of Governors report also names nomadic movement among pastoralist communities as a barrier, along with political interference.
Count who came, and compare it with the population. Who took part shows how, and the result often shows which group to go back for.
Why is record keeping so weak?
The guidelines are blunt: record keeping has been poor or non-existent, and a standard way of storing and retrieving public input would be of great value. They recommend cameras, rapporteurs and a filing system. Without records, a county can't prove what it did, and it can't learn from it either.
Why don't people hear back?
Most exercises stop at the forum. Yet the guidelines ask officials to provide feedback on how public input was used, what was left out and why. The Supreme Court expects that people who made submissions should be able to understand that their input was considered. Reporting back sets out how.
What about politics?
The guidelines and the Council of Governors report both treat political interference as a risk. Forums can be packed by one group or taken over by a dispute that has little to do with the subject. Clear rules, set in advance, help. So does a record that shows who spoke, and a survey that shows what others think.
What should a county do first?
Pick the two weakest links. For most counties those are notice and feedback, and neither is expensive. Then fix the record, because everything else depends on being able to show what happened.
How many people must attend?
There is no fixed number. The guidelines say that no threshold may be objectively prescribed, and that the real question is whether the county structured the process within constitutional and legislative guidelines. They leave any thresholds to county governments.
A high turnout doesn't prove much either. The Supreme Court asks for quality as well as quantity, and a full hall of people from one group is weaker evidence than a smaller, balanced meeting backed by written views and a survey. So record who came, compare them with the population, and explain what you did to reach those who stayed away.
Read next
- Public participation system for Kenya: the TI pack page for this work
- Public participation explained: all the pages in this section
- Why public participation matters
- Methods of public participation
- Who took part
- Takwimu Intelligence (TI) home page
- Public participation in Kenya: the guide to this library
- The TI platform and how we check our numbers
Where TI fits
Takwimu Intelligence (TI) addresses the record problem directly: each notice, view and decision is kept with its date, so a county has the data to learn from every exercise and to show what it did.
To see it on your own consultation, book a walk-through.