Skip to content

guide

Prompted and open recall: why the question decides the answer

A list of names reminds people of what they would never have said. The two questions measure different things, and both are useful.

Takwimu editorial team, Editorial team8 min read

Prompted recall gives people a list of names and asks which they used, while open recall asks the same thing with no list, and the prompted figure usually comes out higher because a list reminds people of what they would never have named.

Key points:

  • Open recall shows what sits in the mind. Prompted recall shows what people recognise and say they used.
  • The gap can be large: in one Pew test, 58% chose an answer that only 35% offered on their own.
  • Ask open first, then prompted, in that order every time.
  • The list decides the result, so build it from what can be received in that county and rotate it.
  • Label every figure with its question, and never compare one type with the other.

What is prompted recall?

Prompted recall offers the names. An interviewer reads a list of stations or shows a card, and the respondent says which they listened to.

It is also called aided recall. It is the standard form for reach, since memory for names is weak and a person may have listened to a station whose name they cannot produce.

What is open recall?

Open recall gives no names. "Which stations did you listen to yesterday?" Whatever comes out is recorded as said.

It goes by other names too: unprompted recall, unaided recall, spontaneous recall, or top of mind when only the first name counts. It needs more work to code, since one station will come back in many spellings and nicknames.

Why do the two give different numbers?

A list does the remembering. It also tells them which answers are acceptable.

Pew Research Center's 2008 test shows the size of this. When offered the economy as a response, 58% chose it. Only 35% of those given the open version volunteered it. And fewer than one in ten of those given the list named something outside it.

So a list pushes up what is on it and pushes down what is left off. That second effect matters for a small station. Leave it off the list and it nearly vanishes.

What does each one measure?

The two questions measure different things, and each answers a business question.

Open recall Prompted recall
What it shows Names held in memory Names recognised and claimed
Tends to favour Strong brands, loyal listeners Whatever is on the list
Use it for Brand strength, presenter fame Reach, share, dayparts
Main risk Under-reports light use Over-claims and confusion
Work needed Coding of answers Building and rotating a list

A station with a large gap between the two has people using it who do not hold its name. That is a branding job. A jingle, a station identifier before each link, and presenters saying the name more often may do more than a new show.

Which question should come first?

Ask open first. Once a person has heard a list, you can never get an unprompted answer from them again.

Pew warns that earlier questions can provide context for those that follow. So the order runs: open, then prompted, then any question that names your station. Never discuss a station or programme by name before the recall section.

How do you build a fair station list?

Build the list from what can be received where the respondent lives. The Communications Authority counts more than 200 radio stations, so no one can hear them all, or hear them all read out. Our page on radio stations in Kenya sets out how the market divides, and TV stations in Kenya does the same for channels.

Follow these rules:

  • Filter by county first, so each person hears only stations audible there.
  • Include rivals you dislike and ones you think are too small to matter.
  • Use the name people say, and add the frequency or slogan where names sound alike.
  • List sister stations separately, with their own names.
  • Always end with "any other", and record it as said.
  • Keep the list the same across waves, apart from real launches and closures.

Who writes the list has power over the result. Publish it with the report. A rival should be able to see that it was on the list.

Does the order of the list matter?

Order changes answers too. It works differently by mode. Pew reports that telephone respondents more often choose items heard later in a list, and that people completing a survey themselves tend to choose items near the top.

So a station read last on every call has a hidden lead. A station at the top of an online form has one too. Rotate the order at random for each interview, and do the same on any show card by printing several versions.

The answer also depends on how you reach people, as a short list suits the phone and a card suits the doorstep.

Does prompted recall overstate audiences?

It can, and the direction is known. Self-report tends to run high. Markus Prior found survey estimates of US network news exposure ran about three times higher than Nielsen ratings on average, while following their trends relatively well.

Add a list and new errors arrive. People confuse names, credit the station they usually hear, or say yes to be polite. Well-known brands gain and new stations lose.

None of this makes prompting wrong. It means the figure is an estimate under a stated method. That is the core position of this library: a recall survey measures what people say they did, and it stands apart from logs, replies and adverts.

How do you test for false recall?

Add a check. Put one plausible station name on the list that does not exist in that county, or a programme that did not air.

The share who claim it gives you a floor for over-claiming. If 4% say they heard a station that is not on air there, a 4% reach on the real list means little. Report that check in your limits section.

How should you report prompted and open figures?

Report them as two lines, each with its question. Here is an invented example for one station, from a sample of 1,000.

Measure Result
Named without a list, yesterday 14%
Said yes from a list, yesterday 23%
Gap 9 points

Read those as two facts. The 23% is your reach estimate. The 14% shows how much of it is held by the name alone.

Compare each only with itself. Moving from an open question in one wave to a prompted one in the next could add many points and nobody would have gained a listener. This trap also appears in published lists of top radio stations, so ask which question sits behind any ranking.

What does this mean for advertisers?

Advertisers meet the same split as spontaneous and prompted awareness of a brand. A brand lift study usually asks both, for the same reason.

Sponsors should be careful with prompted claims. A person shown a list of sponsors may tick a familiar brand that never sponsored the show. Use sponsorship evaluation methods that include a brand that was not involved.

What do practitioners get wrong?

Most errors here come from treating the question as a detail:

  • Prompting first, then asking open questions that are no longer open.
  • Comparing an open wave with a prompted one.
  • Reading the same list order on every call.
  • Leaving small or new stations off.
  • Printing a figure with no wording beside it.

The wider rules are in our guide to audience survey questions, and the method these sit inside is day after recall.

Where TI fits

Whoever writes the question and the list shapes the result, so both belong in the report. Takwimu Intelligence (TI) uses a prompted outlet list in its day-after recall questionnaire, and open answers are coded, so each figure can be read with the question behind it.

To see it on your own station or title, book a walk-through.

Takwimu Intelligence (TI) is audience measurement software for Kenyan media.

Sources

  1. 1

    Writing Survey Questions · Pew Research CenterOpen and closed questions, wording, order, acquiescence and pretesting. Opened 5 November 2026.

  2. 2

    Audience Measurement and Industry Trends Report, August 2026 · Communications Authority of Kenya, August 2026Seven-day access, daily use, place of consumption, radio genres and languages, and the evening advertising window for Q4 2025/26. Opened 5 November 2026.

  3. 3

    The Immensely Inflated News Audience: Assessing Bias in Self-Reported News Exposure · Markus Prior, Public Opinion Quarterly 73(1), 2009Self-reported news exposure tested against Nielsen ratings. Abstract read. Opened 5 November 2026.

More from the library