The Kriegler Commission, formally the Independent Review Commission (IREC), examined Kenya's 2007 general election. Its report found that the conduct of the election was so materially defective that it was impossible for anyone to establish true or reliable results for the presidential and parliamentary votes. It called for an overhaul of the Electoral Commission of Kenya and major changes to election law.
Key points:
- South African Judge Johann Kriegler chaired it.
- It was presented in September 2008.
- It said nobody could tell who won.
- Its findings fed into the reforms that followed.
Why was it set up?
It came out of the mediated deal that ended the crisis. Human Rights Watch says commissions were established to look into electoral fraud and post-election violence. Kriegler dealt with the election, and Waki with the violence.
What did it find?
The central finding is stark. The Daily Nation quotes the report as saying that the conduct of the 2007 elections was so materially defective that it is impossible, for IREC or anyone else, to establish true or reliable results.
Human Rights Watch describes the same conclusion: the process had been so disrupted that it was impossible to tell who won the presidential poll.
What did it recommend?
The headline recommendation was an overhaul of the ECK and major changes in electoral laws. These proposals were broad, covering the institution itself, the voter roll, the law on disputes and boundaries.
Parliament and the people later replaced the old structure. The 2010 Constitution created the Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission, and Article 88 sets out its functions.
How did leaders react?
Both the President and the Prime Minister welcomed the findings and promised to have the recommendations implemented. The report was to go to Cabinet, and then to Parliament through a sessional paper.
The Prime Minister urged the country to own the report in a bipartisan and unified effort. Those words matter, because a report of this kind can easily become one side's weapon.
Why does it matter for peace?
Disputed elections are a leading trigger for violence. If people can't trust a result, they've little reason to accept it. The AFSC study names contested results as a proximate trigger, and it says that low trust weakens confidence in election bodies.
The report showed that the problem wasn't simply bad losers. The system itself had failed.
How does it link with the Waki report?
They should be read together. Kriegler explains why people couldn't trust the result. Waki explains what happened next. The Wilson Center brief says that carrying out both sets of recommendations led to constitutional reform and more peaceful elections in 2013.
What did it mean for institutions?
It showed that an election body needs more than rules. It needs independence, capacity, and public trust. If any of these fail, technical steps won't save it.
It's a useful point for anyone planning election peace work today. Trust in the process is part of the peace plan. The first roadblock in NCIC's Roadmap is a trust deficit.
Is it still relevant now?
Very much so. Kenya has since had further disputes over results, and each cycle tests trust again. The AFSC study says that coordination gaps persist, and that its most likely scenario is contained but persistent local tension.
Peace actors should watch public trust in the IEBC as closely as they watch for hate speech. If it falls, warning signs follow.
What should election managers take from it?
Plan for the tally, and for what comes after. Publish clear results procedures early. Train staff well. Keep records that can be checked. Explain delays quickly, because silence feeds rumours.
What should peace actors take from it?
Help people understand how results are tallied, and how to challenge them lawfully. Bring party agents together before voting. Prepare messages for the hours when results are being tallied, because that's when rumours spread fastest.
What should journalists take from it?
Avoid declaring winners early, and explain the process. The Media Council guidelines set out duties on accuracy, opinion polls and conflict-sensitive reporting. Report tallying problems with care, and check before you publish.
What should voters take from it?
Your agent and your polling station matter. Know how to report a problem. Keep calm, and use lawful routes. A petition is slow, but violence has never given anyone a fairer count.
Where can you read it?
The Parliament of Kenya's online library holds the Report of the Independent Review Commission on the General Elections held in Kenya on 27th December 2007. Read the original where you can, as press summaries cover only part of it.
How should the report be cited?
Name it fully and give the date. Quote its words exactly. Be careful with what it didn't say. It didn't declare a winner. It said that the true result couldn't be known. That's a very different thing.
How can you use it in training?
Ask a team to list what went wrong in 2007. Then ask which of those risks exist in your county today. Who would people believe if results were disputed? Who would calm a crowd? Answering those questions is a good start to a county plan.
What did the Constitution change?
The 2010 Constitution wrote the lessons into law. Article 81 sets general principles for the electoral system, including free and fair elections that are transparent and administered in an impartial, accurate and accountable manner. Article 86 says that whatever voting method is used, the system must be simple, accurate, verifiable, secure, accountable and transparent.
Those words answer the failures of 2007 directly. They also give citizens a standard to hold the IEBC to.
Read next
- Conflict early warning system for Kenya: the TI pack page for this work
- Election violence in Kenya: all the pages in this section
- The Waki Commission
- Post-election violence in 2007
- NCIC Roadmap for 2027
- Takwimu Intelligence (TI) home page
- National cohesion in Kenya: the guide to this library
- The TI platform and how we check our numbers
Where TI fits
Takwimu Intelligence (TI) tracks trust in institutions through repeat surveys by county, which shows a commission where confidence is falling before results are announced.
To see it on your own work, book a walk-through.