The International Criminal Court took up the 2007-08 violence after Kenya failed to set up a local tribunal. Six suspects were accused of crimes against humanity, and all charges were either not confirmed, withdrawn or terminated without prejudice. In November 2023, the Office of the Prosecutor concluded the investigation phase. Nobody was convicted of the violence itself, and victims were left waiting.
Key points:
- Kenya was given time to set up a tribunal, and it didn't.
- A sealed envelope of names reached the prosecutor in 2009.
- Witness problems weakened the cases.
- The court closed its investigation in 2023.
How did the cases begin?
The Waki Commission called for a special tribunal. Human Rights Watch says it recommended one along a strict timeline. A summary of the process says the list of alleged perpetrators was handed to Kofi Annan, who passed the envelope to the ICC Prosecutor in July 2009. Kenya was then given a year to set up a tribunal.
No tribunal came. The matter moved to The Hague.
Who was charged?
Six people were accused, including senior political figures and a radio journalist. We don't name them here, since none was convicted. The record of each case can be read on the court's own website.
How did the cases end?
They ended at different stages. Charges against some suspects weren't confirmed, and others were withdrawn. In April 2016 a Trial Chamber decided by majority that the remaining case should be terminated. One judge dissented.
The Chamber's decision said that it did not preclude new prosecution in the future, either at the ICC or in a national court. So the closure doesn't amount to a finding of innocence or guilt.
Why did they collapse?
Witness problems were central. The Wilson Center brief says one case was ended as the prosecutor cited witness interference and politicisation of the judicial process. Witnesses in a small country are easy to reach, and many were afraid.
What happened to the victims?
They've been let down. A joint statement by seven organisations in 2019 said that both the truth commission and the ICC had failed to ensure justice and redress, and that impunity and suffering prevailed. When the 2016 decision came, a lawyer for victims said that it would be a disappointment to them.
Many survivors never got compensation, medical care or an apology. The TJRC page covers the reparations promised.
What did the cases change?
They brought debate over impunity into the open, and they drew attention to the role of leaders.
The Wilson Center brief also highlights the case against a vernacular radio presenter, accused of using his show to inflame tension. That case ended too.
What about local prosecutions?
Human Rights Watch had urged a tribunal to end the cycle of impunity. Yet the ISS still writes in 2026 that a culture of impunity persists.
Is the investigation over?
In November 2023, Deputy Prosecutor Nazhat Shameem Khan said that, after assessing all the information available, she had decided to conclude the investigation phase.
What does this mean for 2027?
It's a warning. People planning violence may see that nobody paid a price last time. Nation reporting in 2026 notes that those who finance gangs are rarely held to account.
Prevention, then, can't rest on the threat of a court in The Hague. It has to rest on local leaders, police, prosecutors and early response. The 2016 decision left room for a future prosecution, but no one should plan around that.
What does this mean for witness protection?
Anyone documenting violence must plan for witness safety from day one. Don't collect names you can't protect. Keep sensitive records out of shared systems. Know who you'd call if someone was threatened.
This applies to peace committees, researchers and journalists alike. Monitoring without profiling explains safe practice.
What can civil society do now?
Keep records of survivors' needs. Push for reparations through the Restorative Justice Fund. Support memory work. Help survivors speak, if they wish to.
Watch your language too. Survivors and those accused live in the same country, and often in the same county.
How should the cases be written about?
Stick to what the court decided. Say "the case was terminated", "charges were withdrawn" or "not confirmed", as appropriate. Don't say that someone was found innocent or guilty if no such finding was made. Avoid linking a person's community to the case.
What can students and researchers read?
Start with the court's public documents, the International Justice Monitor, and the reports of the Waki Commission and of Human Rights Watch. Read Kenyan voices as well, including those of survivors' groups.
What is the lesson for institutions?
Justice can't be left to an outside court. A country needs prosecutors and judges who can act, witnesses who are safe, and leaders who accept that nobody is above the law. Each of these is slow to build, and each is cheaper than another crisis.
How should you read a termination?
Read it for what it says. The 2016 ruling ended a case by majority, with one judge dissenting, and it left room for new prosecution. It didn't decide who was responsible for the violence.
So it's wrong to say that a person was cleared of all blame, and equally wrong to say that a person got away with a crime. Both claims go beyond what the court decided.
What can a survivor do now?
Options are limited, and they do exist. Survivors can register with victims' groups, take part in campaigns for reparations, and keep their records safe. Human rights bodies and legal aid groups can advise on claims. Those who were displaced can follow the IDP process, and those with land claims can use the National Land Commission.
Read next
- Conflict early warning system for Kenya: the TI pack page for this work
- Election violence in Kenya: all the pages in this section
- The Waki Commission
- The TJRC report
- Post-election violence in 2007
- Takwimu Intelligence (TI) home page
- National cohesion in Kenya: the guide to this library
- The TI platform and how we check our numbers
Where TI fits
Takwimu Intelligence (TI) limits who can see a report, and it keeps identities apart from what is being analysed, which protects people who come forward.
To see it on your own work, book a walk-through.