A good hate speech complaint system takes reports safely, checks them, and shows what happened next. NCIC's chairperson has said the commission relies on formal complaints and won't act on TikTok clips alone, so the quality of a complaint decides what follows. The Standard reports that cases proceed to court only once investigators have assembled watertight files. Intake is where that file begins.
Key points:
- Use clear categories and simple language.
- Collect evidence in the first contact.
- Protect identity, and allow anonymous reports.
- Tell people what happened to their complaint.
What should a complaint form ask?
Start with what happened, where and when. NCIC's form asks people to pick from six categories: ethnic discrimination, hate speech, harassment, incitement to violence, victimisation and other. It's sensible to keep these, so that your data lines up with the commission's.
Ask whether there were other witnesses, whether any media was recorded, whether there's a supporting link, whether it was reported to an authority, how many offenders there were, and whether the person is willing to give their details.
How to report to NCIC explains what a member of the public should do.
Why ask about motive?
NCIC asks, "Why do you perceive this to be motivated by hatred?" That question separates a cohesion complaint from an ordinary grievance. Record the answer in the person's own words. Don't infer motive for them.
Where did it happen versus where do you live?
Keep these separate. The place where something happened is often not where the reporter lives. A person in Nairobi may report a post about Kisumu. If you mix these up, your map will be wrong.
How should anonymity work?
Let people report without a name where you can. Anonymity should be a property of the channel. A witness can still be reached through a reference number, if they wish.
Explain the limits. An anonymous report is harder to prosecute. A person may choose to come forward later.
What channels should you offer?
Offer more than a website. Use a phone line, a walk-in desk, a paper form at county offices, and a link that works on any phone. Offer Kiswahili and local languages. Help people with disabilities, and those who can't read.
What evidence should people keep?
Tell them what to save: the original link, the date and time, a screenshot showing the account name, and any audio or video. They shouldn't edit it. They shouldn't share it further, since that may spread the harm.
How should complaints be sorted?
Sort them by urgency first. A threat to life goes to the police at once. Then decide what kind of matter it is. Some are for NCIC. Others belong to the police, the labour courts, the land bodies, or the public service.
Code what the complaint describes. Displacement or eviction, for instance, may be written up as a land dispute, and you'd miss the pattern otherwise.
How should a complaint be checked?
Follow a verification method. Hold each report as unverified until a person has checked it. Note what supports it. Group reports of the same event, so that one viral clip doesn't look like 500 incidents.
What is the legal test?
Section 13 of the National Cohesion and Integration Act has its own elements. Article 33 protects expression, with limits. Not every offensive remark is an offence. Train the people who take complaints, so that they don't promise more than the law can give.
How do you work with police and prosecutors?
Agree on what each body needs. The Inspector General told the Senate of 12 joint investigations with NCIC, most still under investigation. Defenders of NCIC say that prosecutions depend on evidence, prosecutors and courts.
So keep a clear chain of custody. Note who handled what, and when. Good records can decide a case.
How do you handle a surge?
Plan for one. Rallies, viral clips and election days can bring many reports. Group duplicates. Set a rule for what gets looked at first. Share a holding message, so people know they've been heard.
The National Council of Churches has urged a monitoring and rapid response mechanism for this reason.
How do you close a complaint?
Tell the person what happened: referred, resolved, not pursued, and why. Many complaint systems fail here. People who hear nothing stop reporting.
What reports should you publish?
Publish counts by category and county, with dates and outcomes. Show how long complaints took. Keep names out. Don't rank communities. NCIC's Wall of Shame is one approach to public accountability; if you name anyone, check your legal basis first.
How do you protect staff?
Reading hate speech and threats wears people down. Rotate staff. Offer support. Keep them safe from abuse online and offline.
What can a county do?
A county can run a desk that takes reports and refers them. It can link to NCIC, the County Commissioner, the police and peace committees. It doesn't have to prosecute anyone to be useful.
How do you know it's working?
Measure how many people know about it, how long replies take, what share of complaints are closed, and whether complainants would use it again. Ask those who didn't report why they didn't.
Read next
- Conflict early warning system for Kenya: the TI pack page for this work
- Cohesion monitoring on TI: all the pages in this section
- How to report to NCIC
- Hate speech law in Kenya
- Verifying conflict reports
- Takwimu Intelligence (TI) home page
- National cohesion in Kenya: the guide to this library
- The TI platform and how we check our numbers
- Triage incidents in the situation room
Where TI fits
Takwimu Intelligence (TI) carries a complaint intake built field by field from NCIC's form, with its six categories, its hatred question and a separate incident county.
To see it on your own work, book a walk-through.