Ethnic contempt is an offence under the National Cohesion and Integration Act, covering words intended to incite feelings of contempt, hatred, hostility, violence or discrimination against any person, group or community on the basis of ethnicity or race. The text sets a fine of up to one million shillings, imprisonment for up to five years, or both. A newspaper, radio station or media enterprise that publishes those words commits an offence too.
Key points:
- It targets words intended to incite contempt, hatred, hostility, violence or discrimination.
- The target may be one person, a group or a community.
- The maximum prison term is higher than for section 13.
- Media houses can be liable for publishing the words.
What does the provision say?
It says that any person who utters words intended to incite feelings of contempt, hatred, hostility, violence or discrimination against any person, group or community on the basis of ethnicity or race commits an offence, and shall be liable on conviction to a fine not exceeding one million shillings, or to imprisonment for a term not exceeding five years, or both.
Its second part says that a newspaper, radio station or media enterprise that publishes the utterances commits an offence, and shall be liable on conviction to a fine not exceeding one million shillings.
The Stanford entry for the Act places this in section 62. Be careful with numbering, because the 2022 Bill refers to section 62 in a different way, so check a current copy.
How does it differ from hate speech under section 13?
The wording of section 13 is about threatening, abusive or insulting words or material that stir up ethnic hatred, with intent or likelihood. Ethnic contempt is about words intended to incite contempt, hatred, hostility, violence or discrimination, so intent sits at the centre of it. It can also protect one person, where section 13 speaks of hatred against a group. The prison term is five years, against three.
What does "intended" mean?
The prosecution has to show that the speaker meant to incite those feelings. Courts usually infer intent from the words, the audience, the timing and what followed. A speech to a tense crowd the night before a vote carries a different meaning from the same words in a seminar.
What counts as words?
The provision speaks of a person who "utters words". That covers speech at a rally, on radio or in a sermon. Its second part reaches publication by media. Online posts raise questions that the 2022 Bill tried to answer, by naming electronic and social media in section 13.
What does it mean for media houses?
A media house doesn't have to agree with a speaker to be at risk. If it publishes the words, it may commit an offence. So editors should ask whether quoting the words adds to the public's understanding, or only spreads them. Describe what was said, without repeating it where you can, and say how others responded.
Live programmes carry the greatest risk. Call-in shows on vernacular stations can be useful, and they can go wrong quickly, so train presenters to step in, and use a delay if you can.
What about reporting a court case?
Fair reporting of proceedings is normal journalism, but take care. Stick to what was said in court. Don't add your own commentary on a community. Take legal advice on anything doubtful.
What about politicians?
Politicians are often accused of this offence. The commission has said it acts on formal complaints, and that it looks at evidence before it summons anyone. The Standard reports that few cases lead to convictions. Being summoned or charged isn't a finding of guilt.
What about comedians, musicians and bloggers?
The offence doesn't exempt art or humour. A song or a skit that attacks a community may fall within it, although context matters, and Article 33 protects artistic creativity. Satire aimed at the powerful is very different from mockery of a community.
What should you do if you're accused?
Take legal advice early. Preserve what you said, in full, since a clip can distort. Don't repeat the words in your own defence on social media.
How should a reader treat these cases?
Wait for the facts. An accusation may be political, and a denial may be false. Courts exist for this. In the meantime, avoid sharing clips, since that is how such words spread.
How does NCIC use the term?
NCIC says that its Wall of Shame names perpetrators of hate speech and ethnic contempt, especially those trying to undermine national unity. Its chair has spoken of growing challenges posed by both.
That's a public accountability tool, used by a statutory body. Others shouldn't copy it without legal advice.
Why does contempt matter if no one is attacked?
Contempt comes first. People who've been taught to look down on a group find it easier to accept harm to that group. Dangerous speech explains this link. Contempt also hurts by itself: a child mocked for an accent may stop going to school.
What should a teacher or employer do?
Treat it seriously and early. Stop name-calling. Speak to those involved in private. Record what happened. Explain what's expected. If it's a pattern, follow your complaints process.
What should a family do?
Children learn this at home. A joke at dinner about another community teaches more than a school lesson. Talk about people you know, and let children see you treat everyone with respect.
Read next
- Conflict early warning system for Kenya: the TI pack page for this work
- Hate speech in Kenya: all the pages in this section
- Hate speech law in Kenya
- Hate speech and freedom of expression
- How to complain to NCIC
- Takwimu Intelligence (TI) home page
- National cohesion in Kenya: the guide to this library
- The TI platform and how we check our numbers
Where TI fits
Takwimu Intelligence (TI) helps a media monitor log what was said, by whom and where, with the source kept beside it, and leaves the legal judgement to people.
To see it on your own work, book a walk-through.