Conflict early warning indicators are the specific signs that tension may be rising, such as hate leaflets, youth being mobilised, or people moving their families away. IGAD's CEWARN is the main regional system. A good list is short, local and agreed in advance. Each sign should be something a monitor can observe and report, and it should describe events, never whole communities.
Key points:
- Use a short list that fits your area.
- Mix fast signs, such as threats, with slow ones, such as drought.
- Rate reliability and severity separately.
- Watch for change from the normal level.
What makes a good indicator?
It can be seen, it is specific, and two people would report it the same way. "People are leaving" is good. "Things feel bad" isn't. Each one should link to a possible response.
What are the signs in speech and information?
Watch for leaflets or messages telling a group to leave, a rise in hateful language at rallies or on local radio, and rumours of a coming attack. Also note coded words new to the area. Dangerous speech explains why these matter.
What are the signs in security?
Watch for groups of youth being recruited, paid or trained, the sale or movement of weapons, unusual movement of armed people, attacks on property, and unusual deployments of security forces. NCIC's Roadmap consultation found that 63.4 percent expected violence from unusual security deployments.
What are the signs in politics?
Watch for disputes over party primaries, contested results, rallies being disrupted, opponents being blocked from areas, and leaders refusing to accept a process. Tension often rises around nominations, as well as at the general election.
What are the signs in the community?
Watch for families moving away, or sending children to relatives. Mixed markets may become single-community ones. People may stop trading, or stop using a road. Children may stop going to a shared school. Places where communities are made unwelcome are a serious warning.
What are the signs in land and livelihoods?
Watch for boundary disputes, evictions, new settlers, grazing conflicts, cattle raids and water shortages. Drought can force herders to move, which raises tension with neighbours. Prices and job losses can add pressure too.
How does CEWARN organise indicators?
CEWARN works through national units, and it reviews conflict trends and scenarios with member states. Its reports cover a wide range of concerns. Use the regional picture for context, and your own list for local work.
How do you rate a report?
Use two scales. Reliability asks how sure you are: unconfirmed, one good source or confirmed. Severity asks how serious it would be: low, medium, high or critical. A low-reliability report of a planned attack may still need a quick check. Keep the two apart, so that a rumour doesn't pass for a fact.
How do you use the list?
Agree a baseline, because every area has a normal level of tension. Monitor weekly, more often near elections. Look for change: a new sign, or several signs at once. Hold a short review, and decide on action. Record what you did.
How do you avoid profiling?
Describe acts, never whole groups. Write "armed youth at the market", not a community's name, unless the name is in a direct quote. Don't keep lists of people by ethnicity. Counting events against a community can itself become a tool of harm.
How often should the list change?
Review it after each election or crisis. Drop signs that never helped, and add those you missed. Ask people in the community what they watch for, since they often know the earliest signs.
What are examples of early warning signs in Kenya?
Past experience gives some clues. The 2007 violence followed long grievances over land, and politicians were implicated in organising violence, according to Human Rights Watch. Signs like these rarely appear overnight, which is why regular monitoring matters.
Which signs come at which stage?
Signs change through an election cycle. The AFSC study says that violence peaks during party nominations, campaigns and the post-election period. Plan for each stage.
During nominations, watch disputes over who was cleared, attacks on party offices, and youth hired by rival aspirants. During campaigns, watch disrupted rallies, zoning, inflammatory speech and fake stories. During voting and tallying, watch delays, rumours of rigging, and unusual police deployments. After results, watch street gatherings, attacks on those seen as supporting the winner, and families moving.
What signs did NCIC use in 2022?
Capital FM reports that NCIC used a 13-variable risk matrix. The commission's red flags included ethnic balkanisation and zoning by politicians, increased inflammatory attacks by prominent leaders, and misuse of social media to spread hate speech and incitement.
Your county list doesn't need 13 variables, but it should cover the same ground.
What are the digital signs?
Watch for a sudden rise in posts about one place or community, old clips of violence being recirculated, coded nicknames, and new accounts pushing the same hashtag. Global Voices reported that one influencer ordinarily runs at least 10 accounts, so a lot of noise may come from very few people.
Treat these as prompts to check. They aren't proof of anything.
What are the signs of peace?
Track good news too. Mixed markets stay open. Leaders meet. A rival is allowed to campaign. Residents report a rumour and it's dealt with. Connectors matter as much as dividers, and noticing them tells you what to protect.
Read next
- Conflict early warning system for Kenya: the TI pack page for this work
- Conflict early warning in Kenya: all the pages in this section
- What is conflict early warning?
- Dangerous speech
- From warning to response
- Takwimu Intelligence (TI) home page
- National cohesion in Kenya: the guide to this library
- The TI platform and how we check our numbers
Where TI fits
Takwimu Intelligence (TI) comes with severity rules that name why they fired, from incitement to people expecting violence, and it never counts anything against a community.
To see it on your own work, book a walk-through.