Alternative justice systems are the ways people settle disputes outside the formal courts, such as elders' meetings and community mediation. Article 159 of the Constitution says alternative forms of dispute resolution, including traditional mechanisms, shall be promoted. The Judiciary's AJS Policy, launched in August 2020, seeks to recognise, regulate and enhance them. For peace work this matters greatly, since most disputes never reach a court.
Key points:
- Article 159 supports these systems, within limits.
- Few people with legal problems use the courts.
- Traditional systems must respect the Bill of Rights.
- Women and young people were often left out.
What are alternative justice systems?
They include elders' councils, clan meetings, religious mediators, peace committees and other community forums. One account describes elders hearing both sides, often in public, asking questions, inviting others to speak, and proposing a resolution acceptable to both.
Why do they matter?
Most people don't go to court. The SDG16+ blog says as few as 3 percent of people with legal problems seek justice in the courts, and former Chief Justice Willy Mutunga has said that 95 percent of Kenyans didn't go to formal courts. The Judiciary calls informal systems often more accessible and affordable.
They also repair relationships. A court decides who wins. An elders' meeting tries to keep neighbours living together.
What does the Constitution say?
Article 159(2)(c) says that alternative forms of dispute resolution, including reconciliation, mediation, arbitration and traditional dispute resolution mechanisms, shall be promoted, subject to clause 3. Clause 3 says they must not contravene the Bill of Rights, be repugnant to justice and morality, or be inconsistent with the Constitution or any written law.
Article 60 also encourages communities to settle land disputes through recognised local initiatives.
What is the AJS Policy?
It came out of a task force on traditional, informal and other mechanisms for dispute resolution. The EU delegation says that the EU and UNODC supported that work for two years, and that the policy was launched at the Supreme Court. Chief Justice David Maraga said that it gives effect to Article 159(2)(c).
The Judiciary says that it aligns these systems with the Constitution and international human rights standards, that AJS County Action Plans have been launched in Kajiado and Nakuru, and that a national steering committee holds an annual conference.
What are the limits?
The biggest limit is rights. Dr Mutunga explained that women and youth were often marginalised, as male elders decided that they represented everyone. Under the Constitution, traditional systems must consider equity, gender, inclusiveness, non-discrimination and human rights.
Serious crimes need the police and courts. Elders shouldn't settle murder, rape, defilement or child abuse. A compensation deal can't replace the law.
How does it support peace?
Many conflicts begin as small disputes: a boundary, a stolen goat, a fight at a water point. If a trusted group settles them early, they don't grow.
Peace committees often use these methods. The national peace policy seeks to regulate and institutionalise the part played by local peace committees and councils of elders.
How do elders' decisions relate to courts?
They can work together. The Judiciary says that the systems have helped to resolve a significant number of disputes that would otherwise have burdened the courts. A settlement can sometimes be recorded with a court, so that it has more force. Ask a lawyer how this works in your case.
What about land?
Land disputes are a natural fit, since elders may know the history of a plot. But they can't override a title, or cut out women who have rights. Land conflict covers the formal routes.
What makes a good community process?
It's voluntary, open and fair. Both sides can speak. Women and young people are present. Members with a conflict of interest step aside. The outcome is written down, and reviewed later.
Fees should be modest. Nobody should be pressed to accept a deal because of who the other party is.
How can women take part?
Invite them as mediators, as well as parties. Hold meetings at times they can attend. Let a woman bring a companion. Women's groups can run their own forums, and refer matters onward.
How can young people take part?
Young people may not trust older men to understand their disputes. Youth leaders can sit in, and help to resolve disputes among peers. This matters in places where gangs recruit.
What about religious mediators?
Religious leaders and Kadhis, among others, also resolve disputes. Article 170 deals with Kadhis' courts. Faith leaders often mediate family and community matters, and interfaith peacebuilding covers their wider role.
What should a county do?
Find out who resolves disputes in each ward. Train them on rights. Link them to legal aid and to the courts. Ask the Judiciary about County Action Plans.
What should data collection cover?
Record dispute types, how long they took, and whether settlements held. The role of justice data was central to building the policy. Protect names, and share only totals.
How do you know a process is fair?
Ask both parties afterwards. Would they use it again? Did they feel heard? Did the deal hold? Did anyone feel forced? Simple follow-up is the best check.
What are the critics saying?
Some argue that the aim shouldn't be to formalise these systems. Others worry about pressure on weaker parties. Those are fair concerns, and the answer lies in keeping the process voluntary, open and rights-based.
Read next
- Conflict early warning system for Kenya: the TI pack page for this work
- Peacebuilding in Kenya: all the pages in this section
- Peace committees in Kenya
- Land conflict in Kenya
- National policy on peacebuilding
- Takwimu Intelligence (TI) home page
- National cohesion in Kenya: the guide to this library
- The TI platform and how we check our numbers
Where TI fits
Takwimu Intelligence (TI) gives peace structures a private record of disputes, outcomes and follow-up, with totals that can be shared without names.
To see it on your own work, book a walk-through.